Each year, the Men's All-School Flag Football league champion competes against the league champion from Ithaca College in the annual Cortaca Mug Game. Below are the results from the contest dating back to the first game in the Fall of 2000.
| Year | Host Team | Visiting Team | All-Time Series |
| 2000 | Cortland 32 | Ithaca 31 | 1-0 Cortland |
| 2001 | Ithaca 56 | Cortland 50 | 1-1 Tied |
| 2002 | Cortland 49 | Ithaca 35 | Cortland 2-1 |
| 2003 | Ithaca 46 | Cortland 6 | 2-2 Tied |
| 2004 | Cortland 41 | Ithaca 39 | 3-2 Cortland |
| 2005 | Cortland 45 | Ithaca 25 | 4-2 Cortland |
| 2006 | Cortland 0 | Ithaca 20 | 4-3 Cortland |
| 2007 | Game not played | ||
| 2008 | Game not played | ||
| 2009 | Cortland 30 | Ithaca 34 | 4-4 Tied |
| 2010 | Ithaca 32 | Cortland 39 | 5-4 Cortland |
| 2011 | Cortland 20 | Ithaca 39 | 5-5 Tied |
| 2012 | Ithaca 24 | Cortland 38 | 6-5 Cortland |
